Diptera.info :: Identification queries :: Diptera (adults)
| 
 Sarcophagids ? 
 | 
|
| LordV | 
 Posted on 30-07-2007 09:05 
 | 
| 
Member Location: Posts: 673 Joined: 06.09.05  | 
Bopth pics taken Yesterday at 1:1 uncropped. Assume #1 is Sarcophaga carnaria but is #2 just a small one of the same species ? They were both sitting on a tree stump next to each other. brian v. ![]() ![]()  | 
| 
 | 
|
| ChrisR | 
 Posted on 30-07-2007 11:35 
 | 
| 
 Super Administrator Location: Reading, England Posts: 7706 Joined: 12.07.04  | 
Well, they're all sarcophagids but I wouldn't be so rash as to give them a name    The top one might be Sarcophaga carnaria, "sensu latu" but you need to see the male genitalia to be sure because there are about 6 very similar species     The second one does look a bit different but I'd need to see the specimen to be able to say for sure - scale is a bit hard to judge from close-up photos and they all look very similar from the top     Sarcophagids are worth catching because in my experience you can find quite a few species just by collecting as many different-sized flies as you can on a site.  | 
| Zeegers | 
 Posted on 30-07-2007 11:36 
 | 
| 
Member Location: Soest, NL Posts: 19205 Joined: 21.07.04  | 
Well, pic 1 is a female Sarcophaga, so very difficult to tell the species (if possible at all). Size is not of real importance, although anything < 7 mm. is bound to be NOT carnaria. Theo Zeegers  | 
| 
 | 
|
| LordV | 
 Posted on 30-07-2007 12:54 
 | 
| 
Member Location: Posts: 673 Joined: 06.09.05  | 
Thanks for the info  - just to be useful the smaller fly works out at 7.8mm body length, larger one about 12.4mm body length.brian V.  | 
| 
 | 
|
| Jan HC Velterop | 
 Posted on 23-10-2009 17:09 
 | 
| 
Member Location: Enschede NL 7544 ZE 106 Posts: 56 Joined: 08.03.06  | 
 Zeegers wrote: Well, pic 1 is a female Sarcophaga, so very difficult to tell the species (if possible at all). Size is not of real importance, although anything < 7 mm. is bound to be NOT carnaria. Theo Zeegers I agree with Theo, that the smallest S. variegata or S. carnaria catched by me in nature is only 7 mm long. But I have raised once a group of nearly 20 on 1 earthworm. They finished the whole within good 2 hours. Being afraid for starvation they pupated and came to life again as 5-mm-flies, smaller than I have ever seen. Jan H.C.Velterop.  | 
| 
 | 
|
| Jan HC Velterop | 
 Posted on 23-10-2009 17:12 
 | 
| 
Member Location: Enschede NL 7544 ZE 106 Posts: 56 Joined: 08.03.06  | 
The second fly has only 3 post-DC, forget ID. Jan H.C.Velterop. | 
| 
 | 
|
| Jump to Forum: | 















  The top one might be Sarcophaga carnaria, "sensu latu" but you need to see the male genitalia to be sure because there are about 6 very similar species  
  The second one does look a bit different but I'd need to see the specimen to be able to say for sure - scale is a bit hard to judge from close-up photos and they all look very similar from the top  