Posted by Line Sabroe on 14-01-2014 17:13
#1
Found hiding under decaying leaves in the bird bath in my garden in Aalborg, Denmark on November 24th of 2013.
Length without the breathing tube about 10 mm. feeding on some kind of red-brown algae.
I've come to the conclusion that they are most likely either Helophilus or Eristalis larvae.
Can anyone help with an ID?
Posted by Ectemnius on 14-01-2014 17:47
#5
Hello Line Sabroe,
I would say, under these circumstances, to think about Myathropa florea. I once found larvae in similar conditions and next spring there emerged some nice Myathropa specimens.
Greetings,
Ectemnius
Posted by Line Sabroe on 25-01-2014 15:19
#6
Hello Ectemnius
Thank you for answering, and I'm sorry I've been so long in responding.
I do not think that these are
Myathropa florea larvae. I have checked with a key (Danish book
Danmarks Svirrefluer by E. Torp) and it states that
florea larvae have a much longer breathing tube (about 3 to 4 times the body length) and the front breathing horns should be paler.
There is one more possibility besides
Helophilus and
Eristalis, and that is
Sericomyia silentis - although I only spotted a fly of this species on two occasions, whereas there has been plenty of the other two species on the site. This doesn't rule it out, though. In favour of
Sericomyia silentis is the size and shape of the front breathing horns, that looks rather short and stumpy.
Sadly the quality of the images are not really good enough to clearly show the characters that I need to use the key properly.
Best regards